Friend or Foe? 1 Samuel 20 Analysis

In this compelling analysis, we delve into the profound revelations encoded within the twentieth chapter of 1 Samuel. This portion of the scriptural narrative, nestled within the rich textual tapestry of the First Book of Samuel, provides both a historical account and foundational theological insights central to broader sentiments of Christian faith.

Our exploration will illuminate the enduring, multifaceted conversations between God and His devotees as demonstrated through the relationship between David and Jonathan. As the narrative proceeds, we closely observe the dramatic, spiritual plight of King Saul. Guided by a systematic and thought-provoking approach, we will endeavor to provide rich commentary that draws from an array of biblical resources including the New International Version (NIV), English Standard Version (ESV), and the King James Version (KJV) to ensure a comprehensive analysis.

As 2 Timothy 3:16 affirms, “All scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness,” thus our objective is to illuminate the teachings and lessons nested in this pivotal chapter of 1 Samuel.

Friend or Foe? 1 Samuel 20 Analysis

Exploring the Key Themes of 1 Samuel 20: A Tale of Loyalty and Friendship

Viral Believer is reader-supported. We may earn a small fee from products we recommend at no charge to you. Read Our Affiliate Disclosuree

In 1 Samuel 20, we unearth a timeless tale of loyalty and friendship between David and Jonathan, which remains instructional and inspirational for today’s Christian life. Their relationship is characterized by unwavering commitment, selflessness, and affection that even the threat of death at the hands of Jonathan’s father King Saul cannot waver. The three key themes that are explicitly clear in this chapter include loyalty, friendship, and covenant.

Loyalty is powerfully illustrated in the mutual commitment between David and Jonathan, even in the face of adversity. Jonathan’s loyalty towards his friend David goes as far as protecting him from his own father’s wrath. This is poignantly seen in 1 Samuel 20:4 where he said, “Whatever you want me to do, I’ll do for you”. This teaches Christians the depth of loyalty expected in a relationship and how it surpasses familial ties and personal risks.

Friendship is another strong theme in this story. The symbiotic relation between David and Jonathan is beyond that of shared interests or circumstances. Their friendship is depicted as love, considering 1 Samuel 20:17, “Jonathan made David reaffirm his vow of friendship again, for Jonathan loved David as he loved himself.” This christ-like love, is the cornerstone of a strong christian friendship.

The third theme in 1 Samuel 20 is that of a covenant. Jonathan and David made a covenant before the Lord (1 Samuel 20:16). This was not just a simple contract or agreement, but a solemn and binding pledge made before God reflecting the profound sanctity and significance of their relationship.

By exploring these themes, 1 Samuel 20 provides a rich ground for Christians to assess and build their interpersonal relationships. It encourages us to value loyalty, to love our friends as we love ourselves, and to understand the weight of promises made to one another.

In an overall perspective, this chapter reveals the vital role strong bonds of friendship and loyalty play in fulfilling the plans of God, as it did in David’s ascent to kingship, which directly led to the establishment of the Davidic dynasty, the lineage of our saviour Jesus Christ.

Verses 1-10: An Examination of David’s Impending Danger and Jonathan’s Assurances (1 Samuel 20:1-10)

In the opening verses of 1 Samuel 20, David is in utter confusion about Saul’s intentions toward him and seeks clarification from Jonathan. David poses a daring question to Jonathan in verse 1: “What have I done? What is my crime? How have I wronged your father, that he is trying to kill me?” (1 Samuel 20:1, NIV).

David is confronting the harsh reality of his situation, in which he is being pursued without comprehensible motive. In these lines, we see David’s poignant vulnerability before the absolute power of the king. These verses underscore the precariousness of David’s circumstances.

Jonathan, not yet fully aware of Saul’s intent, offers reassurances to David in verses 2-4. He says to David: “Never! You are not going to die! Look, my father doesn’t do anything, great or small, without letting me know. Why would he hide this from me? It isn’t so!” (1 Samuel 20:2, NIV). While Jonathan’s utterances are indeed provided in good faith, his assurances are without substance as he later discovers the true ferment of his father’s odious intention.

Jonathan’s unawareness is revealed in his statement “But if my father intends to harm you, may the Lord deal with Jonathan, be it ever so severely, if I do not let you know and send you away in peace…” (1 Samuel 20:9, NIV). These verses depict Jonathan as a champion of friendship and loyalty, not yet fully cognizant of the impending peril towards David.

In verses 5 to 10, David elaborates his plan for testing Saul’s affection (or lack thereof). The essence of his plan was to be absent from the new moon feast, a royal event where Saul’s reaction to his absence would reveal his intentions.

This plan ultimately seeks to answer the agonizing binary question David faces – “Am I servant in the eyes of the most powerful man in the kingdom or am I a threat?” “Behold, tomorrow is the new moon, and I should not fail to sit at the table with the king. But let me go, that I may hide myself in the field till the third day at evening” (1 Samuel 20:5, ESV). This tactical maneuver demonstrates David’s resourcefulness and commitment to discern truth, in spite of the danger that surrounds him.

Verses 11-23: Unveiling the Covenant of Friendship between David and Jonathan (1 Samuel 20:11-23)

This passage begins with Jonathan beseeching David out in the fields, “May the Lord be with you as he has been with my father” (1 Samuel 20:13). Jonathan, who is recognized as the rightful heir of King Saul, openly declares his loyalty to David.

He acknowledges David’s right to the throne – an act of defiance against his own family, reflecting his deep-rooted friendship with David. The boldness of Jonathan’s expressions of camaraderie even against his father’s destructive intent underscores the depth of their bond.

A covenant is established between the two in verses 14-17, where Jonathan pleads with David to show kindness to his family once he assumes the throne, “But show me unfailing kindness like the Lord’s kindness as long as I live, so that I may not be killed” (1 Samuel 20:14).

This covenant of friendship, despite the imminent threat from Saul, reflects the trust between Jonathan and David. Instead of his own survival or the continuation of his lineage, Jonathan prioritizes his friend. The extent of this friendship covenant is further revealed through the ritual of oath-taking involving Jonathan’s descendants and David’s expectations of loyalty and kindness.

  • Jonathan, aware of the danger posed by his father Saul, chose David’s friendship over dynastic power, conveying the supremacy of personal relationships over status.
  • Jonathan’s request for kindness towards his family in his absence portrays vulnerability, acknowledging the uncertain future and his unequivocal faith in David’s loyalty.
  • Jonathan’s appeal for mercy for his household after his death further illuminates the depth and authenticity of their friendship. His trust in David supersedes his worries for his lineage and legacy.

Carrying its essence even today, the relationship between David and Jonathan acts as an excellent model of sacrificial friendship and unconditional love, bringing out the subliminal message that love surpasses all boundaries, misunderstandings, and conflicts.

Verses 24-34: The Wrath of King Saul and Its Ramifications (1 Samuel 20:24-34)

In 1 Samuel 20:24-34, King Saul’s wrath toward David escalates dramatically. Earlier, King Saul had been suspicious of David, but in these scriptures, he comes into full anger. This section opens with King Saul eating a meal on the new moon day. David, per his agreement with Jonathan, doesn’t show up.

King Saul does not react on the first day (1 Samuel 20:24-26), thinking that David might be ceremonially unclean – an acceptable reason for his absence. However, on the second day, Saul notes David’s absence again and questions it (1 Samuel 20:27).

When Jonathan explains David’s absence by saying that he had asked permission to attend a family sacrifice in Bethlehem (1 Samuel 20:28-29), King Saul reacts violently. He accuses Jonathan of being shameful and siding with David, whom Saul perceives as a threat to his throne (1 Samuel 20:30-31).

This is an insightful moment: it underscores Saul’s excessive suspicion, his deteriorating relationship with his son, and his confrontational attitude towards David. He is so filled with rage that he even attempts to kill his son Jonathan with a spear (1 Samuel 20:33).

The ramifications of Saul’s wrath are significant. Firstly, his deteriorating relationship with his son deepens the divide in the family and further isolates Saul. Secondly, his unreasonable anger toward David causes a greater rift between them, pushing David, his erstwhile loyal servant, further away.

Lastly, Saul’s actions show that he misinterprets God’s plan – misjudging David when he was the one God had chosen to be the next king (1 Samuel 16:1). In a sense, God’s will is being done, but it is unfolding in a way filled with strife and conflict. In the end, King Saul’s wrath drives a wedge packed with anger and mistrust, ultimately bringing forth an environment of hostility and rejection.

Verses 35-42: The Emotional Parting of David and Jonathan (1 Samuel 20:35-42)

In the morning, at the appointed place, as instructed by Jonathan, David waits for the archer to shoot the arrows, (1 Samuel 20:35). The weight of the impending separation and the dangerous path to be treaded by David reflect in this poignant scenario where they part ways.

Little did they know that this would be the last time these soul friends would see each other. Jonathan discharges his arrows and instructs the lad, thereby covertly communicating with David about the unfriendly intentions of his father Saul (1 Samuel 20:36-38).

What follows is a heart-wrenching scene of parting between two dear friends who shared a God-centered bond, “Jonathan said to David, ‘Go in the peace because we both have sworn in the name of the Lord: ‘May the Lord be between you and me, and between your descendants and mine forever'” (1 Samuel 20:42).

The promise they make to each other is profound and strategic, as it ensures the well-being of their descendants. This covenant of protection not only saved David’s life from Saul but also assured protection of Jonathan’s offspring in the future (2 Samuel 9:1-7).

This scripture teaches us the power of a covenant, indicating its long-lasting impact that goes beyond the lives of the individuals involved. It highlights:

  • The essence of true friendship which seeks the welfare of the other.
  • The example of unswerving faith in God’s promises and steadfast love towards a friend regardless of the circumstances.
  • The strategic and prophetic significance of a covenant only God could fulfill.

The emotional parting of David and Jonathan is a classic example of how God’s promise manifests itself and is a reassurance to us that He keeps His word, even spanning generations (Psalms 105:8).


In conclusion, the vitality of 1 Samuel 20’s message lies in the tapestry of human relationships entwined with divine providence. Within the multilayered context of Israel’s political dilemma, individual loyalties, and spiritual reflections, we are compelled to observe an overriding theme: the gentle but commanding influence of God’s will. The sovereign blueprint of God intertwines David and Jonathan’s unshakeable friendship, Saul’s despairing tyranny, and the eventual rise of David to the throne.

What we learn from this chapter, and indeed throughout 1 Samuel, is that God is intimately involved in the affairs of humankind. He hears the sincere whisperings of human souls and patiently molds the course of history according to His divine narrative. Echoing Proverbs 19:21, “There are many plans in a man’s heart, Nevertheless the Lord’s counsel—that will stand” (NKJV).

Reflecting on 1 Samuel 20 through a charismatic Christian lens widens the purview to see the broader picture of God’s manifested love and transformative power. The charismatic emphasis on the active, experiential presence of God adds a vibrantly spiritual dimension to our interpretation.

In an era yearning for connection and an understanding of destiny, the insights gleaned from 1 Samuel 20 become all the more potent. Let these reflections compel us to embrace the existence of a personal, loving, and interactive God, who is inextricably woven into every fragment of our lives. May we continue to dig more in-depth into the sacred texts, welcoming divine wisdom and connection.

The life-altering dynamics of love, betrayal, friendship, faith, and divine intervention in 1 Samuel 20 continue to echo in our lives today. The resonance of these timeless truths remains a call-to-action for reader engagement with God’s word, individual introspection, and practical application in our contemporary context.

About The Author

Scroll to Top